header banner
Default

Does Halal Forex Trading Exist? | CoinCodex


Forex trading is quite a contentious topic from the perspective of Islamic finance. While trading currencies is considered halal as long as the contract and the exchange itself are conducted in the same sitting, retail forex trading is obviously a far cry from that and many elements of it are considered haram by Islamic scholars. 

Some forex trading platforms try to comply with Islamic finance principles by offering “Islamic accounts” which are operated under different rules than standard account. However, even these “Islamic forex” products are viewed as haram by some scholars.

In this article, we’ll explore the topic of whether forex trading is haram and explain the main reasons why some Islamic scholars and authorities say Muslims should not trade forex. We’ll also highlight an alternative option that can be applicable to Muslims who want to trade in the forex markets while complying with Islamic finance principles.

What is forex trading?

VIDEO: Forex Trading & The Two Conditions for Trading in Stocks | Sheikh Assim Al Hakeem
Just a layman *Sh. Assim Al Hakeem*

Forex trading, also known as foreign exchange trading or currency trading, is the process of buying and selling currencies in the foreign exchange market. The primary goal of forex trading is to profit from the changes in exchange rates between different currencies. 

Forex trading is popular among individual investors, banks, financial institutions, and corporations. It offers the opportunity for traders to profit from fluctuations in exchange rates, but it also carries significant risks, so it's important to have a good understanding of the market and a well-thought-out trading strategy before participating. 

Is forex trading halal or haram?

VIDEO: Is Forex Trading Haram or Halal? | An Insider View
IFG

Trading

Before we tackle the question of whether forex trading is halal or haram, let’s summarize some key takeaways:

  • The physical exchange of currencies, especially if conducted in one sitting, is not considered haram.
  • Standard online forex trading platforms charge rollover interest fees, as well as fees for accessing leverage. Charging interest is prohibited in Islamic finance.
  • Many Islamic scholars argue that forex trading involves elements of maysir (gambling) and gharar (excessive risk taking)
  • Some forex brokers offer “Islamic forex accounts” where users are not charged with interest and currencies are transferred between accounts immediately. 
  • However, even “Islamic forex” products tend to be contentious when analyzed through the lens of Islamic finance.

To help us understand the various arguments for whether forex trading complies with the principles of Shari’a, let’s consider some of the key tenets of Islamic finance.

  • Riba (interest) — Charging interest is prohibited
  • Maysir (gambling / speculation) — Gambling is prohibited
  • Gharar (excessive risk) — One should not engage in transactions that have a high degree of uncertainty or have excessive risks
  • Sharing of profit and loss — Parties involved in a transaction should share the risks and rewards according to the principles of Islamic finance

There are several reasons why forex trading on online platforms is considered haram by many Islamic scholars and authorities.

Many forex trading platforms charge a rollover fee when a trader keeps their position open overnight. From the perspective of Islamic finance, this is considered as riba (interest), which is strictly prohibited. Typically, “Islamic forex” accounts are not charged with a rollover fee, although the broker will usually compensate by making money from the trader in some other way.

When users trade with leverage, they have to pay interest to the broker which is borrowing them funds. This is an example of riba, and is not permitted in Islamic finance.

In addition, trading on forex platforms involves no hand-to-hand exchange of the currencies that are being traded. 

Another reason why forex trading can be considered haram is because it can involve taking excessive risks without engaging in socially beneficial economic activity. Highly speculative trades involving large amounts of leverage involve a lot of unnecessary risk (gharar) are also arguably a form of maysir (gambling), which is prohibited in Islamic finance.

Is trading through “Islamic forex accounts” halal?

VIDEO: Is Forex Trading Haram or Halal? - Dr. Zakir Naik
The Message

As we have already mentioned, some forex trading platforms cater to Muslim traders by offering “Islamic forex accounts” that are treated differently than standard accounts in an effort to be compliant with Shari’a principles.

The most common feature of Islamic forex accounts is that they do not receive any interest payments and are not rquired to pay interest. Islamic forex accounts also don’t have delayed transactions, as currencies are transferred between accounts immediately. Any costs associated with the transaction must be paid at the same time as the transaction occurs.

Sometimes, Islamic forex accounts are also referred to as “swap-free accounts”. A “swap” happens when a trader either pays interest or is paid interest when they leave a trading position open overnight. Islamic forex accounts are not subject to this, as collecting interest is prohibited in Islamic finance.

Of course, brokers do not offer services to users with Islamic forex accounts for free. Instead of interest, they will usually charge various fees and commissions. This can be interpreted as a concealed form of riba.

It’s also possible to view forex trading as gharar (excessive risk) and/or maysir (gambling), although this is more difficult to assess. For example, there is certainly a difference between a knowledgeable trader making forex trading decisions based on in-depth analysis and someone who is making trades on a whim with the hopes of getting lucky making some quick profits.

In our research, we have found that there is no consensus on whether trading forex via Islamic forex accounts is halal or haram, although brokers obviously have an incentive to argue that it is halal. 

The bottom line

VIDEO: Is currency trading ( Forex trading) permissible in Islam? | Dr Muhammad Salah
Ahle Ilm

If you’re someone who wants to trade forex in a manner compliant with Islam, opening an Islamic forex account is quite clearly a better option than using a standard forex account.

Islamic forex accounts offered by various brokers do address some of the issues that make trading through standard forex accounts haram, although there’s certainly no consensus on whether trading forex using “Islamic forex accounts” is in line with the principles of Islamic finance. 

Ultimately, this matter will depend on which scholars and authorities you rely upon for interpretations of Islamic finance principles, as well as your own understanding.

We can safely say that trading forex is more controversial from an Islamic finance perspective than investing in stocks, although some limitations do apply to investor who want to buy stocks in a Shari’a compliant manner. To learn more on the topic, take a look at our article exploring if investing in stocks is haram or halal.

Sources


Article information

Author: Jeffrey Santana

Last Updated: 1700414882

Views: 616

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (115 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Jeffrey Santana

Birthday: 1962-02-21

Address: 087 Rice Forges, Veronicamouth, NV 78201

Phone: +3998651623415224

Job: Teacher

Hobby: Snowboarding, Playing Chess, Survival Skills, Swimming, Embroidery, Playing Guitar, Badminton

Introduction: My name is Jeffrey Santana, I am a forthright, transparent, fearless, Adventurous, Determined, resolute, candid person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.